Week Three Response to Kyla Dr. Watters 450 words
Alcohol Use
Alcohol is one of the most used substances around the globe and is a growing source of public health problems. Alcohol, also chemically referred to as ethanol, is a recreational substance with sedating and potentially addictive properties (Ilhan & Yapar, 2020). Despite the reported harmful effects of alcohol, its use and implication in disease have only begun to be a topic of discussion in the past one hundred years. Not only does alcohol have the propensity to affect the individual negatively, but also the individual’s family, friends, and society (Ilhan & Yapar, 2020). For this reason and several others, alcohol must be regulated with enforceable alcohol use policies. These policies can be evaluated through the lens of Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework and Longest’s policy cycle model to build upon this issue further.
Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework & Longest’s Policy Cycle Model
Kingdon’s Multiple Streams Framework was developed by John Kingdon in 1984 to examine policies and policymaking across various settings (Hoefer, 2022). Kingdon believed that numerous solutions were available for any policy issue and therefore emphasized the ambiguity in defining the problem and the goal due to differing viewpoints among policymakers. Additionally, Kingdon believed that policymakers’ time and resources were limited, further influencing policymaking efforts (Hoefer, 2022). The Multiple Streams Framework can be applied to alcohol use policies and their development in Florida. As outlined by Kingdon, policymakers may differ on whether the economic, social, or physical health detriments of alcohol are the most significant, which may delay the ability to find common ground for policymaking. With limited time and resources, Florida policymakers must address emergencies first rather than debating the most effective solution to harmful alcohol use.
Similarly, Longest’s policy cycle model was developed to map out the health policy cycle and its interrelationships with stakeholders and the healthcare environment (Tsay et al., 2019). This cycle includes three aspects: policy formation, implementation, and modification. Regarding alcohol use policies, Longest’s cycle could be used to map out initial policy formation, guide implementation, and evaluate policy revisions. Ultimately, this policy cycle model could be a helpful adjunct tool to monitor the legislative process for alcohol use policies.
Factors Influencing Implementation
Several factors may affect alcohol use policy implementation. Socially, alcohol is regularly used by 1 in 3 people around the world (Ilhan & Yapar, 2020). For this reason, many individuals may feel oppositional to alcohol use restrictions, which could limit the implementation of policy. Economically, many states benefit from alcohol taxation and may feel less likely to impose alcohol restrictions due to loss of revenue. Contrarily, the environmental impact of alcohol is substantial. Between farming and bottling, alcohol creation is energy intensive (Cook et al., 2024). Substantial water usage is required for alcohol production, and a significant amount of wastewater is created. The restriction of alcohol use may limit demand, which would have a positive benefit on the environment. This may encourage legislators to formulate policy regarding alcohol use, while social and economic factors may inhibit implementation due to potential gain.
References
Cook, M., Critchlow, N., O’Donnell, R., & MacLean, S. (2024). Alcohol’s contribution to climate change and other environmental degradation: A call for research. Health Promotion International, 39(1), daae004. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapro/daae004
Hoefer R. (2022). The multiple streams framework: Understanding and applying the problems, policies, and politics approach. Journal of Policy Practice and Research, 3(1), 1–5. https://doi.org/10.1007/s42972-022-00049-2
Ilhan, M. N., & Yapar, D. (2020). Alcohol consumption and alcohol policy. Turkish Journal of Medical Sciences, 50(5), 1197–1202. https://doi.org/10.3906/sag-2002-237
Tsay, S. L., Tsay, S. F., Ke, C. Y., Chen, C. M., & Tung, H. H. (2019). Analysis of nurse practitioner scope of practice in Taiwan using the Longest policy cycle model. Journal of the American Association of Nurse Practitioners, 31(3), 198–205. https://doi.org/10.1097/JXX.0000000000000127