Use the web or other resources to research at least two crim…
Use the web or other resources to research at least two criminal or civil cases in which recovered files played a significant role in how the case was resolved. Use your own words and do not copy the work of another student. In WORD document Youtube link:
Answer
Title: The Role of Recovered Files in Resolving Criminal and Civil Cases
Introduction:
The advent of digital technology has revolutionized the way evidence is collected and presented in legal proceedings. This includes the increasing reliance on recovered files, which provide crucial evidence that can significantly impact the resolution of both criminal and civil cases. This paper examines two notable cases in which recovered files played a significant role in how the respective cases were resolved.
Case 1: United States v. Ariel Castro
Background:
Ariel Castro, a resident of Cleveland, Ohio, became infamous for the kidnapping and prolonged imprisonment of three women, Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus, and Michelle Knight, between 2002 and 2013. The case gained national attention, and Castro was ultimately charged with multiple counts of kidnapping, rape, and murder. To build a solid case against Castro, investigators turned to recovered files from his computer and other electronic devices.
Role of Recovered Files:
Investigators discovered a series of diaries kept by Castro, in which he meticulously documented his actions, thoughts, and plans related to the crimes. These files provided crucial evidence of premeditation and intent, shedding light on the severity of the crimes committed. Moreover, other recovered files contained graphic photos and videos depicting the victims’ abuse, offering insights into the extent of their suffering during their captivity.
Implications:
The recovered files served as a critical piece of evidence in the prosecution’s case against Ariel Castro. They provided a vivid narrative of his actions, demonstrating his knowledge and intent throughout the period of the crimes. The use of these recovered files played a significant role in substantiating the charges against Castro, ultimately leading to his conviction and sentencing to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Case 2: Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co.
Background:
The legal battle between Apple and Samsung over patent infringement has led to numerous court cases worldwide. In one such case, referred to as Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Apple alleged that Samsung had unlawfully copied various features and designs of their iPhone and iPad models. In this complex civil case, recovered files proved critical in establishing the extent of the infringement and the damages suffered by Apple.
Role of Recovered Files:
Through the use of computer forensic techniques, recovered files provided evidence of Samsung’s intentional copying of Apple’s patented designs and user interface elements. These files included internal communication records, design sketches, and technical specifications. They revealed a pattern of deliberate imitation by Samsung, leading to a strong argument of patent infringement.
Implications:
The recovered files played a pivotal role in Apple’s case against Samsung, allowing them to establish a clear link between Samsung’s actions and the infringement of Apple’s patents. These files demonstrated Samsung’s intent and provided a comprehensive record of their systematic copying. As a result, Apple was able to secure a significant victory, with the court ruling in their favor and ordering Samsung to pay substantial damages for patent infringement.
Conclusion:
Recovered files have become increasingly crucial in resolving both criminal and civil cases. The United States v. Ariel Castro case exemplifies the utilization of recovered files to establish intent and premeditation in a criminal case, while the Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. case highlights how recovered files can demonstrate intent and evidence of patent infringement in a civil case. The use of recovered files as evidence provides a comprehensive and factual account of events, allowing for fair and just resolution in the legal system.