Week 7 Assignment ***Discussion Question (1 Point): Based on your readings, compare and contrast (view any similarities or differences between) the theories of Dr. Marth Rogers and Dr. Rosemarie Rizzo Parse’s theories. Which one would you prefer for your nursing practice and why? Students are to post a total of 3 posts weekly; one original and 2 responses. Remember grammar and punctuation according to APA 6th edition guidelines.
Dr. Martha Rogers and Dr. Rosemarie Rizzo Parse are two prominent nursing theorists who have made significant contributions to the field. This assignment aims to compare and contrast their theories in order to highlight the similarities and differences between them. Furthermore, it will discuss the preference for one theory over the other for nursing practice.
Both Dr. Rogers and Dr. Parse focus on the holistic nature of nursing and emphasize the importance of taking a patient-centered approach. They believe that nurses should view individuals as unique beings with their own experiences and should provide care that is tailored to these individual needs. This is a fundamental similarity between the two theoretical frameworks.
However, there are also several differences in the theories of Dr. Rogers and Dr. Parse. Dr. Rogers developed the Science of Unitary Human Beings, which is based on the concept of the person as an irreducible whole. She argues that the interconnectedness of humans with their environment cannot be ignored and that caring for the person as a whole is essential for effective nursing practice. In contrast, Dr. Parse developed the Theory of Human Becoming, which focuses on the dynamic nature of human beings and the process of becoming. She emphasizes that humans are constantly evolving and that nursing should support individuals in their journey towards self-actualization.
Another difference between the two theories lies in their approach to the concept of time. Dr. Rogers believes that time is an integral part of the human experience and that it should be considered in nursing practice. She argues that time is an important dimension that influences individuals and that nurses should be aware of its impact on health and well-being. On the other hand, Dr. Parse suggests that time is not a linear concept but rather a series of moments that are interconnected. She encourages nurses to be present with individuals in each moment and to focus on the present rather than worrying about the future or dwelling on the past.
The theories of Dr. Rogers and Dr. Parse also differ in their views on the role of nursing interventions. Dr. Rogers emphasizes the importance of noninvasive interventions that allow the person’s energy field to flow freely. She argues that nurses should focus on creating an environment that promotes healing and well-being rather than relying on invasive procedures or medications. In contrast, Dr. Parse suggests that nursing interventions should be collaborative and mutually agreed upon between the nurse and the person receiving care. She believes in the importance of the person’s autonomy and self-determination in the decision-making process.
Considering the similarities and differences between the theories of Dr. Rogers and Dr. Parse, the preference for one theory over the other depends on individual nursing philosophies and practices. Some nurses may find that the holistic approach of the Science of Unitary Human Beings aligns more closely with their beliefs and allows them to provide more patient-centered care. Others may prefer the Theory of Human Becoming, as it emphasizes the dynamic nature of human beings and supports individuals in their journey towards self-actualization.
Ultimately, the choice between the theories of Dr. Rogers and Dr. Parse should be based on an individual nurse’s assessment of their own nursing philosophy and beliefs. It is important for nurses to critically evaluate and reflect on the different theoretical frameworks and choose the one that best aligns with their values and practice. By doing so, nurses can ensure that they are providing the highest quality care that is tailored to the unique needs of each individual.